Judge delays decision in convicted killer Joseph Smith death penalty motion

Sarasota County

SARASOTA, Fla. (WFLA) – Loved ones of a Sarasota girl raped and murdered more than 15 years ago will have to wait another month to learn if her killer will be put to death.

Prosecutors are trying to get Joseph Smith back on death row after his conviction in the 2004 abduction, rape and murder of 11-year-old Carlie Brucia. Smith was sentenced to death but the jury was not unanimous, creating issues years later when the Supreme Court ruled nonunanimous death sentences were unconstitutional.

Smith’s death sentence was vacated in 2017, but then a contradictory Florida Supreme Court decision last month put the option back on the table. Prosecutors filed to re-sentence Smith to death.

In court Tuesday, the judge delayed making a decision on the state’s motion, waiting to see what precedent the state Supreme Court sets in another death penalty case. That ruling is expected later this month.

Those who loved Carlie, like Cheri Langworthy, feel that every delay is a disservice to her memory.

“Makes me very angry, why should he live longer than she did?” Langford asked out loud after court.

She wore a shirt bearing Carlie’s face and name.

“I made this shirt 16 years ago,” she said. “I just feel like people need to remember her.”

Smith is due back in court on March 17.

LATEST NEWS:

Copyright 2020 Nexstar Broadcasting, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Top Videos

Thursday Early Forecast

Thumbnail for the video titled "Thursday Early Forecast"

Tampa Mayor Castor on places of worship order

Thumbnail for the video titled "Tampa Mayor Castor on places of worship order"

Sheriff seeking arrest warrant against local pastor

Thumbnail for the video titled "Sheriff seeking arrest warrant against local pastor"

residents concerned about covid patient

Thumbnail for the video titled "residents concerned about covid patient"

Nurses union protesting lack of protective gear at HCA hospitals

Thumbnail for the video titled "Nurses union protesting lack of protective gear at HCA hospitals"

a group of past and present Tampa Bay Buccaneers decided to help the local community by donating food and supplies to seniors in the area

Thumbnail for the video titled "a group of past and present Tampa Bay Buccaneers decided to help the local community by donating food and supplies to seniors in the area"

Deposit Returned

Thumbnail for the video titled "Deposit Returned"

Tampa woman self-isolating with rescue ducks

Thumbnail for the video titled "Tampa woman self-isolating with rescue ducks"

Hillsborough County to use 2 hotels as quarantine, isolation sites for residents impacted by COVID-19

Thumbnail for the video titled "Hillsborough County to use 2 hotels as quarantine, isolation sites for residents impacted by COVID-19"

Invisible lines in sand cause confusion as Pinellas County beachgoers persist despite coronavirus orders

Thumbnail for the video titled "Invisible lines in sand cause confusion as Pinellas County beachgoers persist despite coronavirus orders"

NFL to begin season as scheduled in September

Thumbnail for the video titled "NFL to begin season as scheduled in September"

Businesses react

Thumbnail for the video titled "Businesses react"
More Local News

Trending Stories

get the app

News App

Weather App

Don't Miss

More Don't Miss