Bayshore homeowners sue to stop Stovall House alcohol sales

Local News

A group of homeowners who oppose Stovall-Lee House becoming a private club had their day in court today.

Nearly two dozen homeowners and the Keep Bayshore Beautiful organization are suing the city, and the house’s attorney joined in defense, over the ‘private residential club‘ the owner wants to establish. 

They’re angry that a party house selling alcohol will now be smack in the middle of one of Tampa’s most prestigious neighborhoods.

Bob Soriano, the attorney for the neighbors who lives right behind the house himself, says this type of venue isn’t allowed in that neighborhood under the city’s zoning laws.



“The bottom line is that this is a ‘large venue’ commercial enterprise in the middle of a residential zoning area,” Soriano said. “Large venues can only be in certain areas of the city under zoning laws–and they’re not permitted in this zone.”

Judge Ralph Stoddard presided over the hearing for partial summary judgement on Thursday.

Blake Casper, the new owner of Stovall-Lee House, didn’t have a comment after the proceedings were completed.

Soriano conceded in court that he may not be able to stop Casper from establishing the club, but that the sale of alcohol in that location is not legal under the city’s zoning laws.

Casper’s attorney, Seth Mills, argued in court that whether they’re selling alcohol or just serving it to private members and their guests, there’s not much difference.

“It’s not a packaging retail store that’s not the primary use of the private recreational club,” Casper said. “It’s an incidental approval.”

The homeowners were unsuccessful in stopping the permitting process at Tampa City Council when they first objected, so they filed this lawsuit.

Soriano said Stoddard could take weeks or even months to make a decision.

Copyright 2020 Nexstar Broadcasting, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Top Videos

Pirate ship themed cruise set to make maiden voyage on Gasparilla

Thumbnail for the video titled "Pirate ship themed cruise set to make maiden voyage on Gasparilla"

Storm team 8 Forecast: Cooler and drier today with a lot of sunshine

Thumbnail for the video titled "Storm team 8 Forecast: Cooler and drier today with a lot of sunshine"

Gasparilla 2020: What to know before you go

Thumbnail for the video titled "Gasparilla 2020: What to know before you go"

Law enforcement runs tight ship to keep 2020 Gasparilla safe

Thumbnail for the video titled "Law enforcement runs tight ship to keep 2020 Gasparilla safe"

Mortgage mess fixed

Thumbnail for the video titled "Mortgage mess fixed"

Veteran relieved after dangerous oak tree removed from near his home

Thumbnail for the video titled "Veteran relieved after dangerous oak tree removed from near his home"

New medical marijuana dispensary opens in Lutz 'There was a tremendous need'

Thumbnail for the video titled "New medical marijuana dispensary opens in Lutz 'There was a tremendous need'"

Politics On Your Side - January 19, 2020

Thumbnail for the video titled "Politics On Your Side - January 19, 2020"

Gasparilla invasion causes headaches for business and residents

Thumbnail for the video titled "Gasparilla invasion causes headaches for business and residents"

Sarasota Beef' O Brady's employee tests positive for Hepatitis A

Thumbnail for the video titled "Sarasota Beef' O Brady's employee tests positive for Hepatitis A"

Path of Destruction: Polk County Deputies investigate why driver of Jeep lost control

Thumbnail for the video titled "Path of Destruction: Polk County Deputies investigate why driver of Jeep lost control"
More Local News

Latest Videos

More Local News

Trending Stories

get the app

News App

Weather App

Don't Miss

More Don't Miss