Bay area cities react to red light camera ruling - WFLA News Channel 8

Bay area cities react to red light camera ruling

Posted: Updated:
LAKELAND, FL (WFLA) -

The Florida State Supreme Court believes some Florida cities jumped the gun when it came to red light camera tickets.

A ruling this week means Orlando might have to pay some people back. 8 On Your Side discovered Lakeland, Brooksville, Bradenton, Temple Terrace might have to as well.

The ruling stipulates that city's that instituted the use of the controversial cameras will have to return fines to drivers who were caught by the cameras before 2010.

Lakeland put up the cameras in 2009 and during that year issued about 20,000 tickets.

But in a class action lawsuit filed in 2012, the city agreed to return a portion of the fines to about a 1,000 drivers who were part of the settlement.

Because of the settlement, Lakeland police spokesman Gary Gross added that Thursday's decision will have very impact on the city.

Gross went on to say, "A majority of these people have paid, there are some that never paid the tickets so a lot of this has already been settled."

Roughly a third never paid the $158 fine and now they're not obligated to pay.

Gross says the ruling has no effect on tickets issued after 2010, and the city will continue to keep the cameras up around Lakeland.

"This is not a comment on whether or not red-light camera tickets are constitutional," Kevin Hayslett, a Clearwater attorney, also told WFLA. "This is a comment on whether or not municipalities followed the rules."

The problem is some cities put up red light cameras before the state okayed them for use on July 1, 2010. Temple Terrace had 3 up, for instance, in late 2008.

"Oh my God! I hate them I hate them! I hate them," said Alex Moran, who believes he might've gotten one back in that time frame. "It's not just been one. I'm always driving and believe me I've paid more than 4."

Hayslett says part of the issue now is if and how to pay people back since each municipality takes a portion of red light camera tickets. The rest goes to the camera company and others.

"So the question is - do they get all of it? Do they get half of it? Is it just for the folks that contested it or is it for everybody," Hayslett explained. "You've got Port Richey that has $1.2 million in play. You've got Temple Terrace that's got $1.4 million in play. They don't necessarily have a secret fund with an extra $1.4 million to pay back to people."

He feels like, ultimately a judge will decide the outcome but that might not come for another couple years. So people who think they might get money back will likely have to wait.

"Now it's up to the courts to determine who pays what and how much," Hayslett noted.

Those municipal legal teams are analyzing what the ruling means and what their next step should be. City spokespeople, like Michael Dunn in Temple Terrace, declined to comment until their attorneys review the ruling.

Josh Thomas & Josh Green contributed to this report.

Copyright 2014 WFLA. All rights reserved.


  • Don't Miss ItMore>>

  • Rappin' Xmas Jammies' family back with new video 'Baby Got Class'

    Rappin' Xmas Jammies' family back with new video 'Baby Got Class'

    Friday, August 22 2014 3:56 AM EDT2014-08-22 07:56:41 GMT
    Image courtesy: www.youtube.com/TheHoldernessFamilyImage courtesy: www.youtube.com/TheHoldernessFamily
    A jammin' North Carolina family who made a Christmas video that went viral last year is at it again. The Holderness family's clever XMAS JAMMIES song featured the pajama-clad family rapping a video version of a yearly Christmas letter.
    A jammin' North Carolina family who made a Christmas video that went viral last year is at it again. The Holderness family's clever XMAS JAMMIES song featured the pajama-clad family rapping a video version of a yearly Christmas letter.
  • Los Angeles port welcomes massive rubber duck

    Los Angeles port welcomes massive rubber duck

    Thursday, August 21 2014 6:26 PM EDT2014-08-21 22:26:58 GMT
     A giant yellow vinyl duck joins sailing ships and motorboats during the Tall Ships Festival L.A. parade in the Port of Los Angeles on Wednesday, Aug. 20, 2014. AP photo Jeff Gritchen/Orange County Register A giant yellow vinyl duck joins sailing ships and motorboats during the Tall Ships Festival L.A. parade in the Port of Los Angeles on Wednesday, Aug. 20, 2014. AP photo Jeff Gritchen/Orange County Register
    The Port of Los Angeles is welcoming an unusual visitor - the world's biggest bath toy. A 60-foot-tall rubber duck sailed into port Wednesday to kick off the Tall Ships Festival
    The Port of Los Angeles is welcoming an unusual visitor - the world's biggest bath toy. A 60-foot-tall rubber duck sailed into port Wednesday to kick off the Tall Ships Festival
  • Peruvian nurse cares for 175 sick cats

    Peruvian nurse cares for 175 sick cats

    Thursday, August 21 2014 12:47 PM EDT2014-08-21 16:47:33 GMT
    In this Aug. 2, 2014 photo, Maria Torero, plays with a group of 175 cats with leukemia in her home in Lima, Peru. Torero says caring for cats with feline leukemia is her responsibility. Anybody else can care for healthy animals. (AP Photo/Martin Mejia)In this Aug. 2, 2014 photo, Maria Torero, plays with a group of 175 cats with leukemia in her home in Lima, Peru. Torero says caring for cats with feline leukemia is her responsibility. Anybody else can care for healthy animals. (AP Photo/Martin Mejia)
    At her job, Maria Torero cares for sick human beings. At home, she lavishes love on slowly dying cats - 175 of them at last count.
    At her job, Maria Torero cares for sick human beings. At home, she lavishes love on slowly dying cats - 175 of them at last count.
  • Most Viewed Stories on WFLA.com

  • Sign up for WFLA News Channel 8 Email Alerts

    * denotes required fields






    Thank you for signing up! You will receive a confirmation email shortly.
Powered by WorldNow

200 South Parker Street, Tampa, FL 33606

Telephone: 813.228.8888
Fax: 813.225.2770
Email: news@wfla.com

Can’t find something?
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Media General Communications Holdings, LLC. A Media General Company.