DOT blames contractor for US 19 overpass girder failure - WFLA News Channel 8

DOT blames contractor for US 19 overpass girder failure

Posted: Updated:
FDOT spokeswoman Kris Carson FDOT spokeswoman Kris Carson
CLEARWATER, FL (WFLA) -

Moments before two semi-tractor trailers struck a sagging beam at the U.S. 19 overpass at State Road 60 in Clearwater May 6, Laura Garrabrant was sitting in her car at the intersection chatting with her sister on a cell phone. Suddenly she saw a 100-ton girder swaying like a piece of canvas in the wind.

"Then the overpass appeared to twist and shift down," Garrabrant told the DOT in an email the next day. "This may have taken 3-5 seconds."

(READ Garrabrant's entire email here)

"She saw the buckling and then the truck hit it," said Florida Department of Transportation spokeswoman Kris Carson. "So we believe it happened very quickly."

Now, the DOT also believes it knows why the beam failed and places blame squarely on the contractor, Hubbard Construction.

The DOT reports that during the demolition of the old U.S. 19 overpass crews cut up the roadway above the steel girders and removed the concrete in sections. According to DOT daily construction logs from April 24-May 6, some of the concrete from the roadway demolition fell into the tub-like girders and workers removed that debris on a daily basis.

(READ a DOT letter to Hubbard Construction)

But the DOT now reports that other concrete chunks apparently fell unnoticed into the crevice between the end of the failed steel beam and the north wall of the overpass, setting in motion a near-disaster.

Because the concrete was wedged tightly into that end space, the beam was not able to expand in the midday heat without deforming. It buckled much like a plastic straw would bend with pressure applied by a fingertip at each end.

"We think that actually prevented the girder from being able to expand and contract with normal temperatures," Carson said. "It just buckled and twisted in the middle."

The result was nearly catastrophic as two semi-tractor trailers struck the sagging 200 foot long girder while driving under the overpass.

An estimated 59,000 vehicles pass through that intersection on any given day. The sagging beam weighed 100 tons and would have crushed anything in its path if it had failed completely and dropped to the pavement below.

"It swayed back and forth as if the wind was gently blowing it," wrote Garrabrant. "It appeared to be in slow motion."

Carson told Eight On Your Side that Hubbard Construction may now face a downgrade of its state contractor rating as a result of the mishap. Financial penalties are also possible due to the forced detour that tied up traffic for two days while road workers removed all four steel beams from the old overpass as part of the $113 million 2.5 mile project to rebuild that stretch of U.S.19.

Meanwhile, Garrabrant won't likely forget what she saw that day and what it sounded like when the truck hit the girder.

"Screeching metal on metal," Garrabrant wrote. "I saw him brake right away and then pull over once he cleared the intersection."

Copyright 2014 WFLA. All rights reserved.



  • Don't Miss ItMore>>

  • 8 fun things to do in Tampa Bay this weekend | July 26-27

    8 fun things to do in Tampa Bay this weekend | July 26-27

    Thursday, July 24 2014 7:10 PM EDT2014-07-24 23:10:36 GMT
    Check out 8 fun things to do this weekend!
    Check out 8 fun things to do this weekend!
  • VIRAL: Silly kitten attacks statue

    VIRAL: Silly kitten attacks statue

    Thursday, July 24 2014 4:55 PM EDT2014-07-24 20:55:04 GMT
    Image from Marina Didone Facebook videoImage from Marina Didone Facebook video
    If you've ever had a kitten, you know how silly they can be when it comes to playtime. A video of a super silly kitten has gone viral on social media with more than 330,000 shares on Facebook 
    If you've ever had a kitten, you know how silly they can be when it comes to playtime. A video of a super silly kitten has gone viral on social media with more than 330,000 shares on Facebook 
  • Sarasota man finds 4-ft-long Tegu lizard

    Sarasota man finds 4-ft-long Tegu lizard

    Thursday, July 24 2014 4:44 PM EDT2014-07-24 20:44:09 GMT
    Billy Baden caught a Tegu lizard behind his home.Billy Baden caught a Tegu lizard behind his home.
    A four-foot lizard that a Sarasota man spotted outside his home shows how much of a problem invasive Tegu lizards have become. Billy Baden caught the Tegu lizard behind his home in the Sherwood Forest neighborhood.
    A four-foot lizard that a Sarasota man spotted outside his home shows how much of a problem invasive Tegu lizards have become. Billy Baden caught the Tegu lizard behind his home in the Sherwood Forest neighborhood.
  • Most Viewed Stories on WFLA.com

  • Sign up for WFLA News Channel 8 Email Alerts

    * denotes required fields






    Thank you for signing up! You will receive a confirmation email shortly.
Powered by WorldNow

200 South Parker Street, Tampa, FL 33606

Telephone: 813.228.8888
Fax: 813.225.2770
Email: news@wfla.com

Can’t find something?
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Media General Communications Holdings, LLC. A Media General Company.